The Refractive Index of Curved Spacetime: the Fate of Causality in QED

Abstract

It has been known for a long time that vacuum polarization in QED leads to a superluminal low-frequency phase velocity for light propagating in curved spacetime. Assuming the validity of the Kramers-Kronig dispersion relation, this would imply a superluminal wavefront velocity and the violation of causality. Here, we calculate for the first time the full frequency dependence of the refractive index using world-line sigma model techniques together with the Penrose plane wave limit of spacetime in the neighbourhood of a null geodesic. We find that the high-frequency limit of the phase velocity (i.e. the wavefront velocity) is always equal to c and causality is assured. However, the Kramers-Kronig dispersion relation is violated due to a non-analyticity of the refractive index in the upper-half complex plane, whose origin may be traced to the generic focusing property of null geodesic congruences and the existence of conjugate points. This puts into question the issue of micro-causality, i.e. the vanishing of commutators of field operators at spacelike separated points, in local quantum field theory in curved spacetime.

arXiv comment43 pages, 19 figures, JHEP3, conclusions respecting microcausality modified

References in corpus (27)

• Causality, Analyticity and an IR Obstruction to UV Completion
• Perturbative Quantum Field Theory in the String-Inspired Formalism
• Worldline Instantons and Pair Production in Inhomogeneous Fields
• Faster-than-c signals, special relativity, and causality
• Born-Infeld Theory and Stringy Causality
• The one-loop effective action and trace anomaly in four dimensions
• ``Faster than Light'' Photons in Gravitational Fields -- Causality, Anomalies and Horizons
• Worldline formalism in a gravitational background
• Quantum Gravitational Optics
• Superluminality and UV Completion
• Faster than light' photons and charged black holes
• Falsifying Models of New Physics Via WW Scattering
• The basis of nonlocal curvature invariants in quantum gravity theory
• Asymptotic behaviours of the heat kernel in covariant perturbation theory
• `Faster than light' photons and rotating black holes
• Causality and Micro-Causality in Curved Spacetime
• Fermi Coordinates and Penrose Limits
• Microcausality in Curved Space-Time
• Faster than Light Photons in Gravitational Fields II - Dispersion and Vacuum Polarisation
• Covariant techniques for computation of the heat kernel
• Accelerating Photons with Gravitational Radiation
• BRST treatment of zero modes for the worldline formalism in curved space
• Nonperturbative late time asymptotics for heat kernel in gravity theory
• A Local Effective Action for Photon-Gravity Interactions
• Covariant Effective Action for Quantum Particle with Coordinate-Dependent Mass
• Path integrals in curved space and the worldline formalism
• Integrals over Products of Distributions and Coordinate Independence of Zero-Temperature Path Integrals

Cited by in corpus (65)

• k-Essence, superluminal propagation, causality and emergent geometry
• Derivation of a Vacuum Refractive Index in a Stringy Space-Time Foam Model
• Einstein-Euler-Heisenberg Theory and charged black holes
• Eikonal phase matrix, deflection angle and time delay in effective field theories of gravity
• From amplitudes to gravitational radiation with cubic interactions and tidal effects
• The Speed of Gravity
• Black Hole Gravitational Waves in the Effective Field Theory of Gravity
• The Causal Structure of QED in Curved Spacetime: Analyticity and the Refractive Index
• Causality in Curved Spacetimes: The Speed of Light & Gravity
• Causality Constraints on Gravitational Effective Field Theories
• Generalized Galileon Duality
• Causality and Micro-Causality in Curved Spacetime
• Reverse Bootstrapping: IR lessons for UV physics
• Asymptotic states and renormalization in Lorentz-violating quantum field theory
• Superluminality, Black Holes and Effective Field Theory
• String Quantum Gravity, Lorentz-Invariance Violation and Gamma-Ray Astronomy
• Gravitational corrections to the Euler-Heisenberg Lagrangian
• Microcausality in Curved Space-Time
• Causality Violation, Gravitational Shockwaves and UV Completion
• Causal structure and algebraic classification of area metric spacetimes in four dimensions
• Quantum mechanical path integrals in the first quantised approach to quantum field theory
• The Refractive Index of Curved Spacetime II: QED, Penrose Limits and Black Holes
• Worldline master formulas for the dressed electron propagator, part 1: Off-shell amplitudes
• Memory, Penrose Limits and the Geometry of Gravitational Shockwaves and Gyratons
• Unitarity and the Vainshtein Mechanism
• The Effect of Gravitational Tidal Forces on Renormalized Quantum Fields
• Decoherence and CPT Violation in a Stringy Model of Space-Time Foam
• Quantum Field Theory in a Multi-Metric Background
• The Effect of Gravitational Tidal Forces on Vacuum Polarization: How to Undress a Photon
• The Quantum Field Theory of K-mouflage
• Constraints on the velocity of gravitational waves from NANOGrav 15-year data set
• Propagation peculiarities of mean field massive gravity
• Gravitational leptogenesis, C, CP and strong equivalence
• Causality, Renormalizability and Ultra-High Energy Gravitational Scattering
• The Unbearable Beingness of Light, Dressing and Undressing Photons in Black Hole Spacetimes
• Flavour effects in gravitational leptogenesis
• Large-scale gauge spectra and pseudoscalar couplings
• Quantum mechanical path integrals in curved spaces and the type-A trace anomaly
• Dynamical Evolution of Gravitational Leptogenesis
• Interactions of Charged Spin-2 Fields
• Microcausality without Lorentz invariance
• New Techniques for Worldline Integration
• High-Energy gamma-ray Astronomy and String Theory
• Bimetric QED
• Effective field theories and inflationary magnetogenesis
• Testing Fundamental Physics in Antihydrogen Experiments
• Photon-graviton mixing in an electromagnetic field
• Low-energy electromagnetic radiation as an indirect probe of black-hole evaporation
• A New Twist on the Geometry of Gravitational Plane Waves
• On the strong coupling scale in Higgs G-inflation
• The IR Obstruction to UV Completion for Dante's Inferno Model with Higher-Dimensional Gauge Theory Origin
• Simplified path integral for supersymmetric quantum mechanics and type-A trace anomalies
• On the simplified path integral on spheres
• Green's function of a massless scalar field in curved space-time and superluminal phase velocity of the retarded potential
• Resolving Puzzles of Massive Gravity with and without violation of Lorentz symmetry
• `Superluminal' Photon Propagation in QED in Curved Spacetime is Dispersive and Causal
• Electric Charge Screening By Non-Minimal Couplings Of Electromagnetic Fields To Gravity
• Graviton Propagation and Vacuum Polarization in Curved Space
• Linearized Lorentz-Violating Gravity and Discriminant Locus in the Moduli Space of Mass Terms
• Entanglement, violation of Kramers-Kronig relation and curvature in spacetime
• Reconsidering Relativistic Causality
• The hypermagnetic power spectra and the phases of Sakharov oscillations
• Do photons travel faster than gravitons?
• Negative superluminal velocity and violation of Kramers-Kronig relations in "causal" optical setups
• Non-Minimally Coupled Einstein-Yang-Mills Field Equations and Wu-Yang Monopoles in Bertotti-Robinson Spacetimes