Thermal derivation of the Coleman-De Luccia tunneling prescription
arXiv:0706.1573 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.76.064003
Abstract
We derive the rate for transitions between de Sitter vacua by treating the field theory on the static patch as a thermal system. This reproduces the Coleman-De Luccia formalism for calculating the rate, but leads to a modified interpretation of the bounce solution and a different prediction for the evolution of the system after tunneling. The bounce is seen to correspond to a sequence of configurations interpolating between initial and final configurations on either side of the tunneling barrier, all of which are restricted to the static patch. The final configuration, which gives the initial data on the static patch for evolution after tunneling, is obtained from one half of a slice through the center of the bounce, while the other half gives the configuration before tunneling. The formalism makes no statement about the fields beyond the horizon. This approach resolves several puzzling aspects and interpretational issues concerning the Coleman-De Luccia and Hawking-Moss bounces. We work in the limit where the back reaction of matter on metric can be ignored, but argue that the qualitative aspects remain in the more general case. The extension to tunneling between anti-de Sitter vacua is discussed.
arXiv comment28 pages, 5 figures; minor rephrasing, typos corrected
References in corpus (10)
- Hard Art of the Universe Creation
- Oscillating bounce solutions and vacuum tunneling in de Sitter spacetime
- Homogeneous Modes of Cosmological Instantons
- On cosmological perturbations in FRW model with scalar field and false vacuum decay
- Negative mode problem in false vacuum decay with gravity
- Hawking-Moss bounces and vacuum decay rates
- False Vacuum Decay With Gravity in Non-Thin-Wall Limit
- The No-Negative Mode Theorem in False Vacuum Decay with Gravity
- The number of negative modes of the oscillating bounces
- False vacuum decay in de Sitter space-time
Cited by in corpus (73)
- De Sitter Musings
- Euclidean wormholes, baby universes, and their impact on particle physics and cosmology
- Electroweak Vacuum (In)Stability in an Inflationary Universe
- Vacuum metastability with black holes
- Cosmological Aspects of Higgs Vacuum Metastability
- Life at the Interface of Particle Physics and String Theory
- Eternal Symmetree
- False Vacuum Decay Catalyzed by Black Holes
- Inflation after False Vacuum Decay: Observational Prospects after Planck
- Spacetime Dynamics of a Higgs Vacuum Instability During Inflation
- A status report on the observability of cosmic bubble collisions
- Standard Model vacuum decay with gravity
- Stochastic Inflation Revisited: Non-Slow Roll Statistics and DBI Inflation
- Populating the Whole Landscape
- The vacuum bubbles in de Sitter background and black hole pair creation
- Negative Modes of Oscillating Instantons
- Schwinger pair production at nonzero temperatures or in compact directions
- Bounces with O(3) x O(2) symmetry
- Higgs Vacuum Stability in a Mass-Dependent Renormalisation Scheme
- A Fresh Look at the Calculation of Tunneling Actions including Gravitational Effects
- Negative modes of Coleman-De Luccia bounces
- Gauss-Bonnet Term on Vacuum Decay
- The Top 10^{500} Reasons Not to Believe in the Landscape
- Dynamics of false vacuum bubbles with nonminimal coupling
- Stretched extra dimensions and bubbles of nothing in a toy model landscape
- Towards a Solution of the Negative Mode Problem in Quantum Tunnelling with Gravity
- Quantum Transitions Between Minkowski and de Sitter Spacetimes
- Bubble collisions and measures of the multiverse
- Black Holes, Oscillating Instantons, and the Hawking-Moss transition
- Oscillating Fubini instantons in curved space
- Instanton solutions mediating tunneling between the degenerate vacua in curved space
- Standard Model vacuum decay in a de Sitter Background
- QCD Axion Window and False Vacuum Higgs Inflation
- Zoology of instanton solutions in flat potential barriers
- Coleman-de Luccia Tunneling and the Gibbons-Hawking Temperature
- Out of equilibrium: understanding cosmological evolution to lower-entropy states
- On thermal false vacuum decay around black holes
- Two interpretations of thin-shell instantons
- On the Limits of Effective Quantum Field Theory: Eternal Inflation, Landscapes, and Other Mythical Beasts
- Exactly Solvable Vacuum Decays with Gravity
- Oscillating instantons as homogeneous tunneling channels
- Hawking-Moss transition with a black hole seed
- Correspondence between Thermal and Quantum Vacuum Transitions around Horizons
- The decay of hot KK space
- Stochastic tunneling for strongly non-Gaussian inflationary theories
- The CMB and the measure of the multiverse
- Recovering the Negative Mode for Type B Coleman-de Luccia Instantons
- Island Cosmology in the Landscape
- Effects of the cosmological expansion on the bubble nucleation rate for relativistic first-order phase transitions
- Vacuum decay and bubble nucleation in gravity
- Tunneling to Holographic Traversable Wormholes
- Gravity waves from cosmic bubble collisions
- Seeded vacuum decay with Gauss-Bonnet
- Positive curvature and scalar field tunneling in the landscape
- Implications of extreme flatness in a general f(R) theory
- Vacuum Decay in General Relativity
- Ground states of semilinear elliptic equations
- Remote Hawking-Moss instanton and the Lorentzian path integral
- Scalar Lumps with Two Horizons
- Multiverse rate equation including bubble collisions
- Instanton Tunneling for De Sitter Space with Real Projective Spatial Sections
- Gravitation and tunnelling: Subtleties of the thin-wall approximation and rapid decays
- JT de Sitter Gravity as a Model of Coleman-de Luccia Tunneling
- Topics in vacuum decay (Ph.D Thesis)
- Comment on Coleman-DeLuccia Instantons
- Exact solutions for Vacuum Decay in Unbounded Potentials
- Consistency between renormalization group running of chiral operator and counting rule -- Case of chiral pion production operator --
- Barnacles and Gravity
- Mean lifetime of a false vacuum in terms of the Krylov-Fock non-escape probability
- Testing Higher Derivative Gravity Through Tunnelling
- Non-minimally coupled gravity and vacuum stability
- Counting the negative eigenvalues of the thermalon in three dimensions
- Instanton interaction in de Sitter spacetime